Shaner's Pizza - Gulf Gate Sarasota

Cindy Brown a month ago

Wow I love the atmosphere and the service.. the salad antipasto was great and full of fresh ingredients.. the thin crust supreme pizza was out of this world.. we had a side of sauce which was not sugary at all but great rich flavor.. the middle of the pizza was cooked perfectly and not undercooked at all the crisp edges were great… definitely come check this place out..

Brian Kelly 2 months ago

Talked with one of the locals at the bar the other night. He told us about Shaner's. We are from Ohio, and good pizza really doesn't exist down here for us. This place was excellent if you like thin thin crispy pizza. Will definitely return.

Ocean Blue Bay 5 months ago

Got to say first time here very excited cuz my daughter picked this place the atmosphere looks good there's a lot of memorabilia on the wall of a of a player who used to play for MLB. Christy who's the waitress very attentive and willing and able to accommodate all services.

MM8 6 months ago

3 words. PHE NOM ENAL! Didn’t know this spot existed. Walking in the vicinity and decided to try. As we peruse the menu my husband sees Shane Rawley. 🤩 Turns into a 13 year old fan on the spot. He actually has a foul ball that Shane pitched to Lenny Dykstra in 1986. Quite the humble gentleman. Fun atmosphere! And, unique but absolutely delicious pizza! Wings were spot on and the desserts were delicious as well. It only took 11 years but we finally found great pizza! Can’t wait to return. 10 stars! ⭐️ ⚾️ 🍕🙌 👏

Steve Metz 7 months ago

Just moved to Sarasota and was looking for a thin crust pizza. This place popped up on recommendations so I gave it a try. I got a pepperoni and sausage pizza and 6 honey BBQ wings. The pizza was great and the wings were yummy also. Paid $34 total for the order. I will probably ask for a little extra sauce next time, but other than that everything was great. I will definitely be back again.